王朝知道
分享
 
 
 

【英语强人系列】原创神话故事推理“芭蕉扇之迷”,多谢指点!

王朝知道·作者佚名  2012-07-24  
宽屏版  字体: |||超大  
 
分类: 教育/科学 >> 外语学习
 
问题描述:

西游记中究竟有几把芭蕉扇,这一直是个迷,我个人觉得有两把,太上老君一把,铁扇公主一把。

理由如下:

1. 见 第五十九回 唐三藏路阻火焰山 孙行者一调芭蕉扇

灵吉笑道:“那妇人唤名罗刹女,又叫做铁扇公主。他的那芭蕉扇本是昆仑山后,自混沌开辟以来,天地产成的一个灵宝,乃太阳之精叶,故能灭火气。假若扇着人,要飘八万四千里,方息阴风。我这山到火焰山,只有五万余里,此还是大圣有留云之能,故止住了。若是凡人,正好不得住也。”

该段落说明扇子功能只是扇风灭火的,并没其他功效!扇人不是主要功能.说明扇子确实是铁扇仙的.

2. “第五十二回 悟空大闹金<山兜>洞 如来暗示主人公”中写到:

老君道:“我那金刚琢,乃是我过函关化胡之器,自幼炼成之宝。凭你甚么兵器、水火,俱莫能近他。若偷去我的芭蕉扇儿,连我也不能奈他何矣。”

这段说明太上老君也有一把,但是降伏兵器用的,在他认为,比金刚琢更厉害!这段也说明是收兵器的,

3. 如果扇子是老君的那把,她就没必要害怕天兵了,直接处理孙悟空就可以了,何必让牛魔王去死拼.

4. 天上的宝贝基本有两种归属,剧情结束必然还要物归原主的,这是必然,但扇子却被孙悟空还给了人家.

5. 如果扇子的确是老君的,最后收复他们的只能是如来,但剧本中写的是哪扎收服的牛魔王,

因此我认为西游记中的“芭蕉扇”就是两把扇子,而且是功能不同的两把!

--------------------------

该段落整个为本人原创,意味奖励原创的朋友,多谢指点!

翻译要求:

1.译文为英文(包括文言文部分)。如果感觉汉语部分哪里不舒服,可以自行修改。

2.要求文字简练,句子结构紧凑,语法正确,地道即可。

3.尽量回避难词,要求精准。

评分标准:依据翻译要求,达到我说的,即可得到悬赏分。

评分规则:

1.14天内如果有一篇鹤立鸡群,直接选为最佳。

2.除非众高手答的都非常令我满意,选三篇好的,进行投票,否则我直接选出。

多谢各位的顶礼支持!谢谢!

参考答案:

The Mystery of the Palm-leaf Fan

How many palm-leaf fans were there in the book "Journey to the West"? This has been a mystery. I personally think there were two, one held by the Supreme Lord Laozi and the other one by the Iron Fan Princess.

Reasons are as following:

1. See Chapter 59 – Tang Sanzang Is Stopped by the Flaming Mountain, Sun Wukong tries to borrow the Palm-Leaf Fan

Lingji smiled: “That woman is called Luosha, also named the Iron Fan Princess. Her Palm-leaf fan was a treasure from the beginning of time, born from Heaven and Earth on the heights of Mt Kunlun. It contains the essence of the sun, so it can extinguish fire. However if a human is fanned, he would be blown away for eighty-four thousand li’s, unable to stop. There are only fifty thousand li’s from my mountain to the Flaming Mountain. It is fortunate you have the ability to stall clouds. An ordinary person would not have been able to stop.”

This explains the Fan’s main function is to extinguish fire, and nothing else! Fanning people is not its main function, hence proving this fan truly belongs to the Iron Fan Princess.

2. Chapter 52 – Wukong upstages Jindou Cave, Buddha hints at his master

Lord Laozi: “My Golden Bracelet is what I used to become an immortal when I passed the Han Gate. I made this treasure when I was a youth. No matter what weapon you may have, or fire and water, none can go near it. Even I will not be able to help you if my Palm-leaf Fan was stolen from me.”

This except shows that the Supreme Lord Laozi had one as well, used to capture weapons. He believes it is even stronger than his Golden Bracelet.

3. If the Fan was the one belonging to Lord Laozi, the Iron Fan Princess would have no reason to fear the heavenly soldiers, she would have the ability to take care of Sun Wukong her self, there would be no need to let her husband the Bull Monster risk his life to fight Sun Wukong.

4. Treasures from heaven basically have two types of resting places. At the end of the book, they must be returned to their owners. But the Palm-leaf Fan was returned to another.

5. If the Fan had belonged to Lord Laozi, only Buddha would have the ability to capture the monsters. However it was Prince Ne Zha who captured the Bull Monster in the book.

Therefore I believe there were two Palm-Leaf Fans in "Journey to the West", two fans with completely different functions!

小贴士:① 若网友所发内容与教科书相悖,请以教科书为准;② 若网友所发内容与科学常识、官方权威机构相悖,请以后者为准;③ 若网友所发内容不正确或者违背公序良俗,右下举报/纠错。
 
 
免责声明:本文为网络用户发布,其观点仅代表作者个人观点,与本站无关,本站仅提供信息存储服务。文中陈述内容未经本站证实,其真实性、完整性、及时性本站不作任何保证或承诺,请读者仅作参考,并请自行核实相关内容。
如何用java替换看不见的字符比如零宽空格&#8203;十六进制U+200B
 干货   2023-09-10
网页字号不能单数吗,网页字体大小为什么一般都是偶数
 干货   2023-09-06
java.lang.ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException: 4096
 干货   2023-09-06
Noto Sans CJK SC字体下载地址
 干货   2023-08-30
window.navigator和navigator的区别是什么?
 干货   2023-08-23
js获取referer、useragent、浏览器语言
 干货   2023-08-23
oscache遇到404时会不会缓存?
 干货   2023-08-23
linux下用rm -rf *删除大量文件太慢怎么解决?
 干货   2023-08-08
刀郎新歌破世界纪录!
 娱乐   2023-08-01
js实现放大缩小页面
 干货   2023-07-31
生成式人工智能服务管理暂行办法
 百态   2023-07-31
英语学习:过去完成时The Past Perfect Tense举例说明
 干货   2023-07-31
Mysql常用sql命令语句整理
 干货   2023-07-30
科学家复活了46000年前的虫子
 探索   2023-07-29
英语学习:过去进行时The Past Continuous Tense举例说明
 干货   2023-07-28
meta name="applicable-device"告知页面适合哪种终端设备:PC端、移动端还是自适应
 干货   2023-07-28
只用css如何实现打字机特效?
 百态   2023-07-15
css怎么实现上下滚动
 干货   2023-06-28
canvas怎么画一个三角形?
 干货   2023-06-28
canvas怎么画一个椭圆形?
 干货   2023-06-28
canvas怎么画一个圆形?
 干货   2023-06-28
canvas怎么画一个正方形?
 干货   2023-06-28
中国河南省郑州市金水区蜘蛛爬虫ip大全
 干货   2023-06-22
javascript简易动态时间代码
 干货   2023-06-20
感谢员工的付出和激励的话怎么说?
 干货   2023-06-18
 
>>返回首页<<
 
 
 
静静地坐在废墟上,四周的荒凉一望无际,忽然觉得,凄凉也很美
© 2005- 王朝网络 版权所有